John Bash, a former law clerk to Justice Antonin Scalia, says a New York Times reporter contacted him before publishing a story that called Scalia's Heller wording a misquote. The paper then ignored his explanation. Bash laid out the exchange in a lengthy LinkedIn post, and Bearing Arms published a critique of the Times piece on November 16, 2026. The Times argues that a single word has distorted Second Amendment law for nearly two decades. Its evidence is narrow: Scalia cited Sir William Blackstone first, and Blackstone wrote "dangerous or unusual" where Scalia wrote "dangerous and unusual." Bash says that gap does not matter, and the article never tells readers he disagreed.
Key Details
The dispute turns on a handful of specific points, and each one cuts against the Times.
- Bash clerked for Scalia during the term District of Columbia v. Heller was decided, and he worked on the case.
- Scalia listed Blackstone first among twelve authorities. Bash says the treatises and cases appear in chronological order, which explains the sequence.
- Scalia introduced the list with a "See" signal, which Bash says signals that the quoted phrase does not come word-for-word from each source.
- Bash argues that the conjunctive version may trace back to a single 18th-century treatise. He says that would not weaken the point that commentators applied the test throughout early American history.
- Bash wrote that he "immediately" sent the reporter an on-the-record explanation. He says the published article "does not refer to my explanation at all."
- Bash also said he would not share private conversations from his clerkship, even if he remembered one about this passage.
- Bash says Hawkins, another source cited in the same passage, was a very influential commentator. He says the order of sources under one signal carries no weight.
Background
Heller came down in 2008. Scalia wrote the 5-4 majority that struck down Washington, D.C.'s handgun ban and recognized an individual right to keep and bear arms. The opinion also said the right is not unlimited. It listed "presumptively lawful" regulations, including felon disarmament, bans on carrying in sensitive places, and prohibitions on dangerous and unusual weapons. Gun control advocates have pointed to that last phrase for years. They argue it lets courts shrink the right to arms in common use. New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen followed in 2022. The Supreme Court held that modern gun laws must be consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. That shift made the historical sourcing of Heller's language far more consequential. Courts now read the old treatises closely, and litigants on both sides cite them. The Times story arrived against that backdrop, and its argument depends on whether the sources support a conjunctive reading.
Why It Matters for Gun Owners
Expect the "dangerous and unusual" argument to show up in courtrooms. Prosecutors and plaintiffs' lawyers in assault weapon and magazine cases already argue that modern rifles fall outside Second Amendment protection. States like Illinois, California, and New Jersey have written those restrictions into law, and challengers in those states are fighting them in federal court. If a judge accepts that a single word in Heller narrows the right, it could reach firearms that millions of Americans own, including AR-15 style rifles and standard-capacity magazines. The risk is not theoretical. Any gun owner in a restrictive state should read the Heller passage in full, along with the Bash post, so they can separate the case law from the spin. Bookmark the original Times piece too. Know the argument your opponents will make before someone in a courtroom or a legislative hearing makes it to you.
DownRange Analysis
Bash's rebuttal holds up under the Bruen framework. Bruen asks whether a regulation fits the nation's historical tradition. It does not ask whether one citation came first or whether a treatise used "or" instead of "and." Bash's point is that multiple authorities endorsed the same limit on weapons that are both dangerous and unusual, and that category sits inside either framing. The Times never answered that. A reporter who wants to overturn a Supreme Court opinion needs to answer the strongest counterargument. This one did not. For the market, the story changes nothing today. Rifles and magazines remain legal in most states, and no court has ruled that Heller's language strips protection from AR-15s. The threat comes from litigation, not from the Times. What should a gun owner do right now? Keep the primary sources handy, back up your arguments with the full Heller text, and share the Bash post. Gun owners lose fights when they rely on talking points. Win this one with the record.




