A Court-Packing Plan Gun Owners Can Get Behind?
HOME›NEWS›LAW
LAW

American Samoa Court Strips Second Amendment Protections Entirely

American Samoa's highest court ruled the Second Amendment does not apply in the territory, effectively nullifying gun rights protections. The decision contradicts constitutional precedent that the Bill of Rights extends to U.S. territories.

Bearing Arms|October 1, 2026|48d ago|2 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

American Samoa High Court Strips Second Amendment Rights Entirely

The High Court of American Samoa has ruled that the Second Amendment holds no force in the territory, declaring constitutional gun rights protections void within its jurisdiction. The decision marks a stark departure from established constitutional law, which treats the Bill of Rights as applicable across all U.S. territories. Gun owners and Second Amendment advocates now face a jurisdiction where federal constitutional protections do not exist.

Key Details

  • The High Court of American Samoa issued a ruling stating the Second Amendment is "utterly meaningless" in the territory
  • The decision effectively eliminates any federal constitutional gun rights protection for residents and U.S. citizens in American Samoa
  • The ruling contradicts longstanding constitutional doctrine that the Constitution applies to all U.S. territories

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

This ruling creates a constitutional dead zone where American citizens lose fundamental rights guaranteed under the Second Amendment. While American Samoa's population is small—roughly 46,000 residents—the precedent is dangerous. If a territorial court can simply nullify the Second Amendment without federal intervention, other territories could follow. Gun owners in Guam, Puerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands, and other territories should assume their rights are now at risk unless the federal court system intervenes. This ruling also signals that territorial governments believe they can ignore Supreme Court precedent, including District of Columbia v. Heller (2008) and McDonald v. City of Chicago (2010), both of which affirmed Second Amendment applicability.

DownRange Analysis

A territorial court ignoring the Constitution's applicability is a federal problem, not a Second Amendment problem—yet. The ruling almost certainly violates the Supremacy Clause and contradicts 14th Amendment incorporation doctrine. However, the fact that a court felt emboldened to issue such a decision without immediate federal pushback suggests weak enforcement or indifference from Department of Justice oversight. Gun owners should monitor whether the federal courts will correct this or allow it to stand. If territories can strip constitutional rights with impunity, the entire incorporation framework collapses, and other fundamental rights follow Second Amendment down.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
american-samoasecond-amendmentterritoriesconstitutional-lawbruengun-rights
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK