ATF: Pastor Russell Fincher’s guns were all destroyed before his Presidential pardon
HOME›NEWS›LAW
LAW

ATF Says Pastor's 39 Guns Were Destroyed — No Video Exists

ATF Director Robert Cekada told pastor Russell Fincher that agency staff destroyed every gun seized from him, including 39 firearms on paperwork dated June 12, 2026. The destruction was not recorded on video, and a SAF FOIA request now seeks the footage.

SAF|November 19, 2026|1h ago|5 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

ATF Says Pastor's 39 Guns Were Destroyed — No Video Exists

ATF Director Robert Cekada told pastor Russell Fincher that agency staff destroyed every firearm taken from him, and Fincher cannot recover any of them. Fincher received a presidential pardon from President Donald J. Trump on Sept. 2, 2026, but the guns were already gone. Cekada's own text messages now say the agency's facilities do not record the destruction process. The Second Amendment Foundation's Investigative Journalism Project filed a Freedom of Information Act request on Tuesday for the video Cekada first described. The pardon restored Fincher's standing. It did not return a single rifle, pistol, or magazine he owned.

Key Details

The timeline and numbers in this case do not line up cleanly, and the gaps matter for anyone with property in federal custody.

  • The raid: In 2023, about a dozen ATF agents in tactical gear with AR-15s entered Fincher’s home. They handcuffed him and kept him outside for more than an hour while others searched the house.
  • The seizure: Agents took more than 50 personal firearms, including a Wilson Combat, five Glocks, and a Polytech pre-ban milled underfolder AK worth thousands of dollars.
  • The charges: A federal grand jury returned a three-count indictment. Two counts were felonies: engaging in the business of dealing firearms without a license, and selling ammunition to a prohibited person. The third was a misdemeanor for making a false entry in the records of a federal firearms dealer.
  • The plea: Fincher pleaded guilty to selling ammunition to a felon. Both sides agreed to three years of probation, and he agreed not to contest forfeiture of his personal firearms.
  • The destruction date: A “Report of Destruction” supplied by Cekada lists 39 guns destroyed on June 12, 2026.
  • The conflicting account: Fincher says Cekada told him the guns were destroyed in August 2026, which would fall after the June date on the report.
  • The location: Fincher says Cekada placed the destruction at an ATF facility in West Virginia.
  • The video: Cekada first said the destruction was videotaped. He later texted that the cameras were installed for general security and may not have recorded the process.

Background

Fincher’s case began with a federal raid and ended with a plea deal that carried a forfeiture waiver. During plea talks, Fincher says the prosecutor agreed he could keep his guns if he sold them. The ATF objected, and that objection killed the deal. Fincher put it bluntly: the agency took the higher-end guns, and he kept the lower-end ones. The pardon came later, and the pardon wording was “full and unconditional.” A pardon erases the conviction and its penalties. Property already forfeited under a plea agreement is a separate question, and it is one the pardon did not answer.

The case is part of a larger pattern. Fincher is among several former gun dealers who say the Biden-era ATF targeted licensed sellers aggressively. Patrick “Tate” Adamiak’s case followed a similar path. Fincher’s own account of the raid, including agents handling and commenting on his collection, raises the same concern about how seized property is inventoried and tracked. Under the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, the government must justify gun regulations by reference to the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. That test governs whether a law can restrict possession. It does not govern whether the government can lose or destroy property it lawfully seized.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

Any gun owner who has dealt with a federal seizure should read this case closely. Federal agencies hold property for months or years. Plea agreements can include forfeiture terms that are easy to sign and hard to undo. If an agency says a firearm was destroyed, the owner may have no practical way to verify it. The paperwork is the only record. Fincher’s case shows that a document labeled “Report of Destruction” can conflict with what the agency director says aloud.

Owners in any state should take three steps. First, demand a complete itemized inventory with serial numbers before signing any property or forfeiture document. Second, ask for a written destruction receipt that identifies each firearm and the date and facility of destruction. Third, if the paperwork and the verbal account do not match, file a FOIA request early. Fincher’s case also shows the value of asking for a copy of your collection’s value and the condition of each gun when it was taken. Owners with high-value firearms, like a pre-ban milled AK, should document photographs and serial numbers before any surrender.

DownRange Analysis

Bruen decides what the government can regulate. It does not decide whether the government keeps its own records straight. This case turns on property and due process, not on the scope of the Second Amendment. Any court asked to return the guns would look at the forfeiture waiver, the destruction report, and whether the government can prove what it destroyed. A pardon restores civil rights. It does not guarantee a remedy for property the government already disposed of.

The market angle is real. Fincher’s guns included a Wilson Combat and a pre-ban AK. Those are the kinds of firearms that hold value, and a sudden loss of that value is a loss to the owner. Gun owners should treat every federal seizure as a potential permanent loss until the government proves otherwise. Get the serial numbers. Keep your own photos. Read every forfeiture clause before you sign. Watch the SAF FOIA request for the video, and do not accept a verbal assurance as a substitute for a document.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
atfrussell-fincherpresidential-pardonfirearm-forfeiturefbi-seizuresecond-amendment-foundationfoiaatf-destruction-records
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK