Colorado and Denver Point at Each Other Over Carry Rights in Court
On November 11, the State of Colorado and the City and County of Denver filed briefs opposing a preliminary injunction in Gene Hoffman v. City and County of Denver. The Firearms Policy Coalition brought the case on behalf of Hoffman, a California resident. Both governments defend their own carry rules and ask the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado to ignore how those rules work together. That request is the problem. A visitor does not get to pick which government's law applies to him. He gets both, at the same time, and the combination leaves him with no lawful way to carry in Denver. The filings avoid that question entirely.
Key Details
The fight centers on two claims that each government uses to cover for the other.
- Colorado's position: The state argues its laws permit open carry. The filings do not mention that Denver bans open carry within city limits.
- Denver's position: The city argues that Hoffman's carry permits from other states authorize him to carry concealed. Colorado does not recognize those permits for a California resident, according to FPC.
- Filing date: November 11, 2026.
- Court: U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado.
- Plaintiff: Gene Hoffman, an FPC member and California resident.
- Named defendant in the injunction request: DA Walsh.
Denver's brief also asks for narrow relief. If the court grants an injunction at all, Denver wants it limited to Hoffman alone. The city argues federal courts cannot grant injunctive relief to nonparties who have not asked for it. FPC President Brandon Combs responded that the two briefs read like something out of The Wizard of Oz, with each government pointing away from the rule that actually applies. Combs said the Supreme Court has already held that peaceable Americans may carry in public for self-defense. FPC cited its earlier win against California's nonresident carry ban as proof that fundamental rights do not end at state lines.
Background
The Second Amendment case law that governs this dispute turned sharply in 2022. In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, the Supreme Court struck down New York's discretionary public carry licensing scheme. The Court also set a new test. When the Second Amendment's plain text covers a person's conduct, the government must show that its regulation fits within the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. Courts no longer weigh a law's policy benefits against its burden on gun owners. They ask whether history supports the restriction.
Colorado and Denver each have their own history of carry regulation. Colorado generally allows open carry, while Denver has long restricted it within city limits. Local ordinances like Denver's sit alongside the state's rules, which is exactly why the overlap matters here. Hoffman's suit asks the court to examine both laws together, because that is how a visitor experiences them. FPC's position is that neither government has pointed to any historical tradition of disarming otherwise-qualified Americans because they live in another state.
Why It Matters for Gun Owners
Anyone who travels with a firearm into Colorado should read this case closely. A nonresident with a valid permit from another state may face a carry landscape that changes block by block. The state may say open carry is legal. The city may ban it. The city may say your out-of-state permit covers concealed carry. The state may refuse to recognize that same permit. You can end up complying with one government's law while violating the other's.
The practical risk falls hardest on people who do not live in Colorado. Residents at least know which local rules apply to them. Visitors often do not know that a city ordinance overrides the friendly state statute they read online. Hotel stays, business trips, and weekend drives through Denver all create exposure. If you carry in Colorado, check Denver's ordinances before you walk out the door. Do not rely on a state summary or a permit reciprocity map alone. Watch the Hoffman docket for the court's ruling on the injunction request. A decision that grants relief only to Hoffman would leave every other nonresident in the same bind.
DownRange Analysis
Under Bruen, the government's framing matters less than the government's burden. Colorado and Denver cannot justify a restriction by pointing to a different law that someone else wrote. The question is whether the combined scheme fits within historical tradition. Denver's brief offers no historical analogue for a rule that disarms a peaceable traveler because of his home address. Colorado's brief offers none for ignoring the city ordinance that blocks the open carry it touts. Courts should see the trap for what it is. Two sovereign rules that cancel each other out do not produce a right to carry. They produce a gap.
Gun owners should treat this as a live warning. Carry in Denver only with a full understanding of both state and local law. Keep your out-of-state permit, your residency documents, and your travel records organized. If you live outside Colorado and plan to visit, consult an attorney familiar with Colorado firearms law before you travel armed. Support FPC or other litigants pressing these cases, because the outcome will shape how states treat visitors nationwide.




