Delaware Wants a Do-Over on Its Ghost Gun Ban Loss
HOME›NEWS›LAW
LAW

Delaware Asks Federal Judge to Reverse Its Own Ghost Gun Ruling

Delaware Attorney General Kathy Jennings wants Judge Maryellen Noreika to undo her September 10 ruling that struck the state's ghost gun bans. The state now calls its rules routine serialization requirements. FPC says that argument is nonsense.

TTAG|November 14, 2026|4d ago|5 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

Delaware Asks Judge to Reverse Ruling Striking Ghost Gun Bans

Delaware wants a second pass at a federal ruling that gutted its ghost gun bans. Attorney General Kathy Jennings filed a motion on October 8 asking U.S. District Judge Maryellen Noreika to reverse her September 10 decision in Rigby v. Jennings. That ruling permanently barred Delaware from enforcing its bans on possessing unserialized firearms and unfinished frames or receivers. It also blocked the state from restricting home building, assembling, and 3-D printing of firearms. The Firearms Policy Coalition (FPC) and plaintiffs John Rigby and Alan Knight won the case. They filed the challenge in 2021. The state's new argument is that these were never bans at all, just serialization rules. FPC answered with a 21-page opposition filed November 12.

Key Details

The numbers and dates in this fight matter, so here they are in one place:

  • September 10: Judge Noreika issues a permanent injunction against Delaware's possession and manufacturing bans.
  • October 8: Delaware files a motion under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 59(e) asking the court to alter or amend its judgment.
  • November 12: FPC files its 21-page opposition in Rigby v. Jennings.
  • September 1: The Third Circuit decides United States v. Berger, upholding minimal, objective federal suppressor registration requirements. Delaware cites it as support.
  • September 3: Governor signs House Bill 418.
  • Six months: H.B. 418 gives current owners of unserialized firearms and unfinished components a window to get those items serialized through a licensed FFL dealer or render them permanently inoperable.
  • No. 26-3575: The Third Circuit appeal of the ruling is stayed while the district court handles post-judgment proceedings.

Judge Noreika applied the framework from New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen and found both the possession ban and the manufacturing ban unconstitutional. She rejected Delaware's public-safety defense. The record, she found, showed nothing that made privately built guns more dangerous than traditionally manufactured, serialized ones. The ruling did not clear everything. Delaware's limits on commercial distribution and its ban on distributing certain 3-D printing files remain in force. FPC President Brandon Combs called the state's position "complete nonsense" and argued that H.B. 418 does nothing for Rigby and Knight. Both men had already surrendered their property, and the statute gives them no path to recover it.

Background

Ghost guns are firearms a person builds at home from a kit or from raw materials, without a serial number. Delaware's bans were among the broadest in the country. They reached possession of guns that owners had made themselves, not just sales by manufacturers. The state's problem began when the U.S. Supreme Court decided Bruen in 2022. That decision requires the government to show that a gun regulation fits within the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. Judges can no longer simply weigh a state's policy interests against gun rights. Courts across the country have since been testing older gun laws against that text-and-history standard.

Ghost gun rules have also faced federal scrutiny. The Supreme Court upheld the ATF's 2022 frame-or-receiver rule in Bondi v. VanDerStok in 2025, but that case addressed federal regulation of kits and unfinished frames for sale, not a state's outright ban on home manufacture. Delaware's lawmakers responded to the Noreika ruling with H.B. 418, a narrow fix that addresses existing property rather than future building. The state's appeal to the Third Circuit and its new motion show that Delaware is still trying to keep the bans alive.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

If you live in Delaware, the practical rule right now is simple. You may possess and build unserialized firearms under the September 10 injunction, but only within the limits the court left in place. The commercial distribution restrictions still apply. So does the ban on distributing certain 3-D printing files. Anyone selling parts, kits, or printed files needs to read the order closely before doing business. A garage builder who sells a receiver to a neighbor could still run into trouble.

Owners who held off on building or buying unfinished parts because of the old ban can now reconsider. Still, the safest course is documentation. Keep receipts for parts and records of build dates. Watch the district court docket, because a ruling on Delaware's Rule 59(e) motion could change the picture fast. If Noreika grants the motion, the bans could return on short notice. Gun owners in other states with similar restrictions should also track this case, since it sets a template that other plaintiffs will cite.

DownRange Analysis

Delaware's Rule 59(e) motion has a timing problem. The rule requires a motion to alter or amend a judgment within 28 days of entry. Noreika issued her ruling on September 10, and the state filed on October 8. That is exactly 28 days. The motion is timely, so the court has to address it on the merits. The bigger problem is the argument itself. Calling a possession ban a "serialization rule" does not fix the fact that the state criminalized the act of keeping a gun you made. Under Bruen, the state has to produce historical analogues. Delaware's brief leans on Berger, but a suppressor registration case says little about a ban on home manufacture. A court will see that gap. Our read is that Noreika will not reverse herself. Gun owners should treat the injunction as firm for now, keep their paperwork clean, and avoid selling anything the order does not clearly permit.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
ghost-gunsdelawaresecond-amendmentbruenfirearms-policy-coalition3d-printed-gunsrigby-v-jennings
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK