New York Convicts Gun Owner Over Legal eBay Parts, Sentencing Looms
Demetrio Daga sits in the Albany County jail after a New York jury convicted him of 15 weapons counts in September. The case did not start with a shooting, a threat, or a victim. It started with New York State Police watching eBay orders. Investigators saw Daga buying springs, pins, and other lawful components. Prosecutors then told the jury he built an arsenal at home. The state never claimed he misused a single firearm. He had never been arrested before. County Court Judge Andra Ackerman presided, and she has pushed sentencing back to Nov. 30.
Key Details
The jury heard a seven-day trial before reaching its verdict. The convictions break down as follows:
- One count of Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the First Degree
- Two counts of Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the Second Degree
- Three counts of Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the Third Degree
- Nine counts of Criminal Possession of a Firearm
Daga was not convicted of manufacturing firearms, even though Deputy Chief Assistant District Attorney Jessica Blain-Lewis made that claim in closing arguments. The entire investigation belonged to the state police. No local, other state, or federal agency took part.
Sentencing was originally scheduled for October. Judge Ackerman moved it to Nov. 30 and gave no reason on the record. Daga's defense team says the judge wants a new pre-sentence investigation report. The first report, prepared by the Albany County Probation Department, recommended probation with no jail time. Daga sat for the second interview on a Tuesday. By his account, it lasted less than five minutes. He told the interviewer he works 12-hour shifts in the jail kitchen. The judge has already said she may not follow her probation department's recommendations.
Daga faces decades in prison on paper. He has two sons, and the younger one recently turned eight. His family says the boys are the hardest part of this for him.
Background
New York's weapons statutes sit in Penal Law Article 265, and the degree of each charge depends on the specific conditions the prosecution must prove. The state layered tighter rules on top of that framework with the SAFE Act in 2013. Since then, New York has steadily expanded restrictions on components, unserialized receivers, and home-built firearms.
The Supreme Court changed the constitutional terrain in 2022. In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, the Court struck down New York's proper-cause requirement for carrying a handgun in public. The decision set a text-and-history test for gun laws. Under that test, the government must show that a regulation fits within the country's historical tradition of firearm regulation.
Federal policy on parts shifted too. ATF's 2022 frame-or-receiver rule drew heavy litigation. In Bondi v. VanDerStok, the Court upheld that rule in 2025. Springs and pins, however, have generally not been treated as regulated firearms on their own. That gap is central to why a case built on purchased parts draws attention.
Why It Matters for Gun Owners
Any New Yorker who buys gun parts online should pay attention. Investigators used a buying pattern as their starting point. They did not need a crime scene. Parts that are legal to buy can become evidence when the prosecution frames them as a collection. Order volume, timing, and the inventory found at a home can all become the story.
Owners in New York should keep clean records. Save invoices, shipping confirmations, and proof of what each part was for. Know which items your state treats as regulated components and which ones it does not. Do not assume a federal rule answers the state question. New York law often goes further than Washington.
Gun owners in other states should watch this case too. Several states copy New York's approach to components and home manufacturing. A conviction built on parts and intent could become a template for prosecutors elsewhere. Anyone who builds from kits or stockpiles components should understand their state's rules before the next order ships.
If you face an investigation, stop talking and call an attorney who handles firearms cases in your state. Do not explain your hobby to a detective without counsel present.
DownRange Analysis
The Bruen test should decide this case, and it leaves room for argument. The Second Amendment protects keeping arms at home, and assembling a lawful firearm for personal use falls within that conduct. The defense must show that New York's counts reach ordinary home activity. The prosecution must then show a historical analogue for punishing it. That is a hard showing for a state built on purchased springs and pins, with no allegation of misuse and no prior record.
Watch the Nov. 30 sentencing. The new PSI and the judge's choice will reveal how much weight New York courts give to intent versus conduct. A jail term for a first-time offender with no violence would send a strong message to every parts buyer in the state.
Right now, New York owners should audit their parts inventory and keep purchase records. Out-of-state owners should check their own statutes. Do not wait for a verdict to learn what your state considers a component. The state already decided this case started with a shopping cart.




