DOJ Looking at Options in Montgomery County Gun Law Challenge
HOME›NEWS›LAW
LAW

Federal Judge Dismisses DOJ Suit Against Montgomery County's 100-Yard Gun Ban

A federal judge in Maryland threw out the Justice Department's challenge to Montgomery County's 100-yard firearms restriction, finding the government unlikely to win. The DOJ says it is weighing its next move, including a possible appeal.

Bearing Arms|November 12, 2026|6d ago|4 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

Judge Dismisses DOJ Suit Against Montgomery County's 100-Yard Gun Zone

U.S. District Judge Theodore Chuang of the District of Maryland dismissed the Justice Department's lawsuit against Montgomery County's firearms restriction for public places. In a 33-page opinion issued Monday, Chuang wrote that the federal government was not likely to prevail. The county law, passed as an emergency measure in July, bars guns within 100 yards of government buildings, parks, and schools. The DOJ has not committed to a course of action. Justice Department spokesperson Kiersten Pels said Tuesday by email that the department is assessing the decision and next steps. The dismissal removes the federal government from the case for now. The county's carry restriction stays on the books.

Key Details

The ruling and the law carry several specifics that matter for anyone who carries in Montgomery County.

  • Court and judge: U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, Judge Theodore Chuang.
  • Ruling date: Monday, with a 33-page written opinion.
  • Law: Passed as an emergency measure in July, prohibiting firearms within 100 yards of public locations such as government buildings, parks, and schools.
  • Narrowed scope: The county removed hospitals, healthcare facilities, childcare facilities, and other locations from the list to comply with a separate court ruling, according to Chuang.
  • DOJ's claims: The department argued the law violates the Second Amendment. It also invoked the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994.
  • The 1994 statute: It lets the attorney general sue to end a “pattern or practice” that deprives people of federally protected rights.
  • County defense: The county argued the DOJ offered no evidence that county police engaged in a pattern or practice of violations under the new law.
  • Chuang's finding: He wrote that the complaint contained no allegations of actual conduct by law enforcement officers tied to the new law. The complaint was filed about one week after the law took effect.

Background

The Justice Department's theory rests on a statute with a specific origin. Congress passed the 1994 crime bill's pattern-or-practice provision after the 1991 beating of Rodney King by Los Angeles police officers. It targets systemic abuse by government actors, including police departments. Using it against a gun ordinance is a stretch, and Chuang's ruling turned on that gap. The Second Amendment question sits in a different place. In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022), the Supreme Court struck down New York's may-issue permit scheme and replaced the old means-end analysis with a test grounded in text and historical tradition. Bruen also noted that some sensitive places may be regulated, which has left lower courts to sort out where the line falls. Maryland's ordinance tests that line with a 100-yard radius, a distance far larger than a single building or school grounds. Any appeal from Chuang's order would go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

Anyone with a Maryland carry permit who lives, works, or drives through Montgomery County needs to treat this ordinance as active law. The dismissal does not strike the restriction. A 100-yard radius around parks and schools covers a lot of ground in dense suburbs. In some neighborhoods, overlapping buffers from several locations could leave no practical place to carry. Pull up the county's map before you head out. Do not assume a location is open because it looks like an ordinary street or shopping area. Check the locations the county actually lists, and remember that the narrowed list no longer excludes hospitals and childcare facilities. Gun owners in other jurisdictions should also watch closely. Local governments often copy language that survives early challenges, and a ruling that a federal plaintiff lacked the right tool to sue could encourage similar ordinances elsewhere.

DownRange Analysis

Chuang's ruling is procedural, and gun owners should read it that way. He did not rule the 100-yard zone constitutional. He ruled that the DOJ's pattern-or-practice theory did not fit the facts it pleaded. That distinction matters because the Second Amendment claim itself has not been decided on the merits. The DOJ's strongest argument is that the law's existence chills lawful carry, which is a burden in itself. Whether a federal judge accepts that theory is a separate question, and the Fourth Circuit may take it up. Under Bruen, the county must point to historical analogues for a buffer this large around parks and schools. A 100-yard radius pushes well past what most sensitive-place rules have historically covered. Gun owners should not wait for the courts. Carry with the county map in hand, document where the restriction applies, and contact the Montgomery County Council about the ordinance. Support the groups litigating Maryland carry cases, because the next ruling may come from a private plaintiff with standing that the DOJ lacked.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
montgomery-countymaryland-gun-lawsdoj-second-amendmentsensitive-placesbruencarry-restrictionsfourth-circuit
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK