Florida AG Won't Enforce State's Ban on Bump Stocks
HOME›NEWS›LAW
LAW

Florida's AG Won't Defend Its Bump Stock Ban Anymore

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier will no longer defend convictions under the state's 2018 bump stock ban. His written opinion calls the law unconstitutional under the Second Amendment. Prosecutors still carry the charges, so Florida owners should not treat the opinion as a court ruling.

Bearing Arms|November 16, 2026|2d ago|4 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

Florida's AG Won't Defend Bump Stock Convictions, Calls Ban Unconstitutional

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier says his office will not defend any conviction under the state's 2018 bump stock ban. He made the call in a written opinion that labels the law unconstitutional under the Second Amendment. The ban sits inside the package passed after the shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland. Uthmeier argues bump stocks are protected "arms," and he says the state cannot show a historical tradition of banning them. The opinion does not bind courts. It does tell every state prosecutor in Florida where the top lawyer stands, and it lands while people are still being charged under the statute.

Key Details

The opinion covers a specific set of facts and arguments. Here is what matters:

  • Who: AG James Uthmeier, through a written legal opinion.
  • What: The office will not defend convictions under the 2018 bump stock ban, which carries a five-year prison term.
  • Scope: Uthmeier says bump stocks fall within "arms" whether the state calls them firearm components or accessories.
  • Lawful use: He says bump stocks are widely used for lawful purposes and do not make semi-automatic firearms more dangerous.
  • Burden: Because the ban touches the plain text of the Second Amendment, the state must prove the law fits within the historical tradition of firearms regulation. Uthmeier says he found no evidence of such a tradition for banning rate-of-fire components.
  • Limit he acknowledges: Government could regulate components that truly convert a semi-automatic into a machine gun. Uthmeier says bump stocks do not do that, since each trigger pull still fires one shot.
  • Missing data: He did not disclose how many people have been prosecuted under the bump stock ban.
  • Other laws: The AG has also declined to defend the ban on sales to adults under 21 and the three-day waiting period. The Supreme Court denied cert in the NRA's challenge to the age ban, which leaves an Eleventh Circuit ruling upholding it in place.
  • Waiting period case: U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday refused a joint judgment from the plaintiffs and the AG. He ordered adversarial briefing and invited Gov. Ron DeSantis, the Florida legislature, and the legal arms of Brady and Giffords to file briefs.
  • Trigger unclear: The source could find no active lawsuit against the bump stock ban.

Background

Florida passed its post-Parkland package in 2018 as the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Act, SB 7026. Governor Rick Scott signed it that March. The bump stock provision made possession of a bump stock a crime, and the age restriction and waiting period came in the same law. Florida's ban grew out of a national fight over the same devices. After the 2017 Las Vegas shooting, the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives reclassified bump stocks as machine guns in a 2018 rule. In Garland v. Cargill (2024), the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that a bump stock does not convert a semi-automatic into a machine gun under federal law, because it does not produce more than one shot per single trigger function. That ruling removed the federal ban. Florida's statute stayed on the books. Since then, the Second Amendment test set in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022) has required governments to match modern gun laws to historical analogues. Uthmeier's opinion applies that test directly to Florida's law.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

Florida owners now have a clear state position to point to. Anyone facing a bump stock charge should call a defense attorney today and cite the opinion in the case file. Defense counsel can argue that the state's top lawyer has declined to defend the statute, but the judge still decides the charge. Pending cases do not disappear by memo. Watch the county state attorneys, because the opinion sends a signal, not an order. Uthmeier himself expects some Florida prosecutors to keep enforcing the law. If you own a bump stock, document the purchase, keep receipts, and do not transport or use it without legal advice. The gap between federal and state law is real. Federal law no longer treats bump stocks as machine guns under the Cargill ruling, but Florida still criminalizes them. Owners who cross state lines or buy online need to understand which law applies where they stand.

DownRange Analysis

The Uthmeier opinion is strong on the text and history. Bruen puts the burden on the government, and Florida has no good answer on rate-of-fire regulation before the twentieth century. Cargill already told us that a bump stock fires one shot per trigger function. The state's best argument is that a device which lets a shooter cycle the trigger faster is a regulated component. That argument has weight with some judges, which is why this will likely reach a court and not stop at an AG memo. The market impact should stay small. Bump stock demand has been modest since 2018, and this opinion will not change production or sales. The real value is the legal precedent it creates for challenges to other Florida gun laws. Do not treat the opinion as permission. Treat it as leverage for your defense attorney and a sign that the state is splitting on Second Amendment enforcement. Keep your paperwork clean, stay informed on Judge Merryday's waiting period case, and watch the Eleventh Circuit closely.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
bump-stocksfloridasecond-amendmentjames-uthmeierbruenparkland-lawwaiting-periodmachinegun-rule
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK