Illinois Judge Clears Self-Defense Shooting, But Felon Gun Charge Sticks
An Illinois judge acquitted Edward Massey, 36, of second-degree murder after ruling he fired in self-defense. The same judge, John M. "Mo" Madonia, convicted Massey of possessing a firearm as a felon. The shooting happened in July 2025 and killed ReKeea T. Jackson-Mason, a 36-year-old mother of three. Massey now faces two to ten years in prison. Madonia will sentence him in mid-January, and Massey will receive credit for time served. The verdict splits the case in two: the man who fired the fatal shot walks on the homicide, but the gun that let him survive puts him behind bars.
Key Details
The trial record lays out a sequence that started at a bar and ended a block away from it. Here is what the court heard and ruled:
- The victim: Jackson-Mason was part of a group that included Massey. After they left a bar, Massey drove toward his home.
- The sunroof incident: Testimony says Jackson-Mason stood up through the sunroof of Massey's vehicle. When Massey told her to sit down, she attacked him.
- The injuries: Jackson-Mason threw a drink at Massey and struck him in the head. Massey suffered a gashed arm, a contusion on his lower back, a broken nose, and a split lip that needed stitches. Madonia said the wounds "weren't superficial."
- The husband: Jackson-Mason contacted her husband, Mark Mason Jr., who had also been at the bar. Mason drove across town. Madonia said he did not arrive as a peacemaker and "arrived with ill intent."
- The gun: Massey testified that Mason had a gun when the assault began. He said the weapon fell, the two men fought over it, and he ended up holding it. A police detective testified that Massey called the gun a "gift from God" at the scene. The court never established where the gun came from.
- The Massey-owned pistol: Madonia noted that Massey could have gone into his home before the fight escalated and armed himself with a Kel-Tec .380. Police later took that pistol from him.
- The ruling: Madonia found Massey's belief that he needed to defend himself was reasonable. He called the single shot a justified response that was not excessive.
- The defense reaction: Massey's attorney said he was disappointed in the felon-in-possession conviction.
Background
Self-defense and felon gun bans have collided in court for years. In District of Columbia v. Heller (2008), the Supreme Court recognized an individual right to keep and bear arms for self-defense in the home. The same opinion called prohibitions on felons possessing guns "presumptively lawful." Federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), bars anyone with a felony conviction from possessing a firearm or ammunition. Illinois layers its own rules on top through the FOID Act, and its felon-in-possession statute operates independently of the homicide charge.
The Supreme Court's 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen changed the test for gun laws. Now the government must show that a regulation fits within the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. Courts have split on how that applies to felon bans. The Third Circuit, sitting en banc in Range v. Attorney General (2024), held the federal ban unconstitutional as applied to a man whose only felony was a nonviolent one. The DOJ responded by building a process for restoring gun rights under 18 U.S.C. § 925(c). Massey's sentencing will fall into this unsettled space, even though his case arrived through state court.
Why It Matters for Gun Owners
This case shows how a self-defense win can still end in a conviction. Any gun owner with a prior felony faces this risk. A prohibited person who carries or keeps a gun for protection commits a crime the moment the gun is in his hands, regardless of whether the shooting itself was justified. Prosecutors can separate the two issues and charge the possession even after a jury or judge rules out the homicide. The defense never gets a complete pass for the gun, even when the facts favor the defendant.
Illinois residents with prior convictions should review their FOID status before they carry, store, or even borrow a firearm. Gun owners anywhere should also think carefully about any weapon they take from an attacker. Massey claimed he took Mason's gun in the fight, but the court still focused on the Kel-Tec in his home. Physical control of a gun can create liability, even when the person holding it never chose to carry it. Owners in states with strong felon-possession enforcement, including Illinois, Illinois' neighbors, and other states with active state-level prosecutors, should understand these rules before a bad night forces the question.
DownRange Analysis
Under Bruen, the self-defense finding here carries the stronger argument. The judge accepted that a man facing a violent assault could respond with lethal force, and that principle reflects the history the Court demands. The felon-possession conviction is harder to defend under the same framework. A prohibited person's right to self-defense does not disappear, but the government can still disarm him under the Court's "presumptively lawful" language. The clash between those two positions will reach appellate courts eventually, and this case could become a vehicle for it.
For gun owners, the practical lesson is simple. If your record bars you from owning a gun, you have no lawful self-defense option with a firearm, no matter what the facts show. Check your eligibility now, not after a fight. If you qualify for restoration, file for it through the federal process as soon as it opens. Massey's attorney has a path to challenge the sentence and rights status, and any gun owner in a similar spot should watch how the sentencing in January plays out. The judge's words about the trigger pull will matter as much as the sentence length.




