Massachusetts High Court Upholds Under-21 Firearm Carry License Restriction
HOME›NEWS›LAW
LAW

Massachusetts Top Court Says No Carry License Under 21

Massachusetts' highest court upheld the state's age-21 carry license requirement 5-2 on October 20. The ruling in Commonwealth v. Thomson rejected a facial Second Amendment challenge and affirmed a conviction involving a 20-year-old's discarded handgun. It binds state courts only.

Concealed Nation|November 16, 2026|2d ago|4 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

Massachusetts Court Says No Carry License Until Age 21

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled 5-2 that the state's age-21 requirement for a license to carry is constitutional. The October 20 decision in Commonwealth v. Thomson rejected a facial Second Amendment challenge and affirmed the conviction of Mikai Thomson, who was 20 when police recovered a semiautomatic handgun he tossed while fleeing a traffic stop. Justice Gabrielle Wolohojian wrote for the majority. The court held that keeping guns from people too young to handle them safely outside supervised settings fits the nation's regulatory tradition. The statute at issue is Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 140, Section 131, which bars anyone under 21 from obtaining a carry license.

Key Details

The facts of the case are simple, and they drive the outcome. Police stopped a car in December 2021 after a red-light violation. Thomson rode as a passenger. According to the court, he ran and discarded a semiautomatic handgun. A jury-free conviction followed for carrying a firearm without a license, and he appealed on constitutional grounds.

  • Decision date: October 20, 2026
  • Vote: 5-2, with two justices dissenting on the historical analysis
  • Defendant's age at the time of the seizure: 20
  • Stop trigger: red-light violation, December 2021
  • Standing ruling: Thomson could bring a facial challenge, but he could not bring an as-applied challenge because he never applied for or was denied a license
  • Majority method: assumed, without deciding, that under-21s belong to "the people" under the Second Amendment, then compared modern licensing rules with founding-era militia rules and youth-possession laws
  • Dissent: would have remanded to a lower court for an expanded evidentiary record, including expert testimony, instead of resolving the tradition question on the existing briefs and the court's own research

Background

Since the U.S. Supreme Court decided New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen in 2022, state and federal courts have asked one question: does the government's regulation match the historical tradition of firearm regulation? Massachusetts courts must now apply that test to a licensing rule that predates the modern debate. The age-21 limit operates as a barrier to the license, not as an outright possession ban for every citizen under 21. That distinction shaped how the majority framed the case.

The bigger issue sits in federal court. Circuits have split on whether adults aged 18 to 20 hold full Second Amendment rights when it comes to handgun purchases and carry. The Fifth Circuit has pushed back on federal limits, while the Eleventh Circuit has upheld Florida's under-21 purchase restrictions. The Massachusetts court acknowledged that this split remains unresolved. Its decision does not settle the question for the federal circuits, and it does not bind them.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

If you live in Massachusetts and you're 18 to 20, this ruling closes the door on a carry license for now. You can still hold a Firearm Identification Card in some circumstances, but you cannot carry in public under a license regardless of how well you shoot or how clean your record is. Anyone turning 21 gains eligibility to apply, and the application process still runs through local licensing authorities with their own discretion.

The case also matters for anyone who travels. A carry license issued in one state does not transfer across state lines in every case, and Massachusetts' rules are among the most restrictive in the country. Gun owners who cross state lines with a handgun need to check each state's age and licensing requirements before they leave. The decision shows that an age limit can survive review by a state high court when the court ties it to historical youth-supervision practices. Expect other states to borrow that reasoning.

Thomson's facial challenge also tells you something. Because he never applied for a license, he could not raise an as-applied claim. Future plaintiffs who want to challenge age limits will likely need a documented denial or application on file. Start building that record if you plan to challenge a restriction.

DownRange Analysis

The majority's historical argument is thinner than its tone suggests. Militia rules and laws governing minors show that the founders expected young men to train under adult supervision. They do not show that a 20-year-old lacked the right to carry a handgun in public. The majority gets around this by assuming the right applies and then finding a tradition of age-linked supervision. That approach invites a fight over which analogues count under Bruen and Rahimi. The dissent's call for an evidentiary record is the stronger procedural argument, because it forces the state to prove the tradition rather than assume it.

Right now, the practical advice is simple. If you're under 21 in Massachusetts, do not carry. If you're over 21, apply for the license and document any denial in writing. If you live in a state with its own age rules, verify them with the issuing authority before you carry or transport a handgun. Watch the federal circuit decisions, because a split that reaches the Supreme Court will decide this question for everyone.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
massachusettssecond-amendmentcarry-licenseunder-21bruencommonwealth-v-thomsongun-law
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK