New Study Challenges Everything Gun Control Advocates Say About Armed Teachers
HOME›NEWS›NEWS
NEWS

Study: Armed Teachers Logged Zero Accidental Shootings in 26 Years

A Crime Prevention Research Center study by John Lott found no shooting-attack deaths or injuries near class hours at schools that allow armed non-uniformed staff, from 2000 through 2025. The same schools recorded no accidental teacher discharges on students, and no police shootings of armed teachers.

Bearing Arms|November 19, 2026|6h ago|4 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

Armed-Staff Schools Logged No Shooting Casualties in 26 Years

Schools that let authorized teachers and other non-uniformed staff carry firearms recorded no deaths or injuries from shooting attacks during or near class hours between 2000 and 2025. The Crime Prevention Research Center, through researcher John Lott, tracked the incidents. The same data shows no teacher accidentally shooting a student, no student grabbing a staffer's gun to hurt someone, and no police officer mistakenly shooting an armed teacher. Those three objections dominate every debate over armed school staff. Lott's 26-year record now sits against them.

Key Details

The study covers schools across the country, where hundreds of districts employ thousands of armed staffers. Its figures break down by security model:

  • Armed-staff schools (2000–2025): No shooting-attack deaths or injuries during or near class hours. No accidental teacher shootings of students. No student use of a teacher's gun to harm anyone. No police shootings of armed teachers.
  • Schools with uniformed armed officers: 39 attacks produced casualties other than the attacker. Officers accidentally discharged firearms 20 times, with more incidents tied to struggles or private guards.
  • Officer misidentification: In three cases, officers shot someone other than the intended target or a bystander they misidentified. All three occurred at schools where state law barred teachers and permit holders from carrying.
  • Schools with neither officers nor armed staff: 551 incidents, the largest total by far.
  • Share of schools: Armed officers protect about 44.5 percent of schools. About 42.2 percent have neither officers nor armed staff.
  • Adjusted rate: Schools without armed protection saw casualty-producing attacks at 14.9 times the rate of schools with armed officers.

The study also cites a May 25, 2021 incident at Lincoln Elementary School in Ogden, Utah. A 41-year-old man tried to kidnap an 11-year-old girl on the playground. She broke free and ran inside. The man chased her and tried to force his way into the building. A teacher with a concealed carry permit drew his pistol and held the man at gunpoint until police arrived. Mississippi state Rep. David Myers (D-McComb) has warned that teachers and principals can have bad days and lose control. Lott's answer: a vetted, trained employee does not become a threat simply because he carries.

Background

The federal Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990 made it a crime to possess a firearm within 1,000 feet of a school. The Supreme Court struck down that version in United States v. Lopez (1995), holding that Congress exceeded its Commerce Clause power. Congress rewrote the statute in 1996 with a jurisdictional hook and kept the core ban. Many states still bar carry on school grounds, which is why the study's split between states that permit staff carry and states that prohibit it matters.

After the 2018 shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, the state created its Guardian program, which lets trained, screened school staff carry on campus. Texas has run school marshal and guardian programs for years. The debate has since moved from theory to real staffing decisions in hundreds of districts. In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022), the Supreme Court set a text-and-history test for gun regulations. States now defend school carry bans under that standard, and challengers use it to attack them.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

This study lands on the desks of school board members, state legislators, and parents who have to choose between security models. If you live in a state that allows armed staff, such as Texas or Florida, your district may already have a program or may soon consider one. Ask whether your board has adopted a written carry policy, who selects participants, and what training they require. Training standards vary widely, and a thin course protects no one. If you live in a state that bans carry on school grounds, the data makes a direct case for repeal. Watch bills in your legislature that change school carry rules, and show up to board meetings where the question gets raised. Parents should also learn how their district's staff security plan works. Ask whether armed staff members are on the roster, and ask how many hours of range and scenario training each one completes.

DownRange Analysis

The study is a strong argument, but not a settled one. Its counts are small, the window is 26 years, and the incidents that happened are few. A zero is a clean headline, but a zero across a small sample tells you less than it sounds like. The Crime Prevention Research Center is also a pro-carry research group, and gun owners should read its methods closely before quoting its numbers in a school board fight. The Bruen test cuts both ways here. A state that bans carry on school grounds must point to historical analogues that justify the ban. Armed school staff have a long statutory history in some states, and that history helps the carry side in court. Market-wise, expect demand for concealed carry holsters, training courses, and school-specific security certification to grow in states that expand staff carry. What should you do right now? Know your state's school carry statute, check your district's policy, and support a training standard that a skeptical parent would accept. The strongest version of this argument wins on training and transparency, not on slogans.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
armed-teachersschool-carryconcealed-carrycrime-prevention-research-centerjohn-lottschool-safetysecond-amendment
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK