Federal Judge Tosses DOJ's Suit Against Montgomery County Gun Rules
On Monday, November 9, 2026, Judge Chuang of the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland dismissed the Justice Department's lawsuit against Montgomery County. DOJ claimed the county's sensitive places law violated the Second Amendment. The county enacted that law in July 2026 as Bill 23-26E. It now sits in Chapter 57 of the county code. The ordinance bans carrying a firearm within 100 yards of a "place of public assembly." The judge granted the county's motion to dismiss. DOJ's broader argument failed too. The government tried to turn a civil rights statute into a weapon against a local gun law, and the court refused to let it.
Key Details
The ordinance covers a long list of locations. Public and private parks, places of worship, schools, libraries, recreational facilities, government buildings, polling places, courthouses, and legislative assemblies all fall under the 100-yard buffer. So do multipurpose exhibition facilities such as fairgrounds and conference centers.
- November 9, 2026: Dismissal date, U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland
- Bill 23-26E: Enacted July 2026, codified at Chapter 57 of the Montgomery County Code
- 100 yards: Distance from a place of public assembly where carrying is prohibited
- Pattern-or-practice statute: 34 U.S.C. § 12601, which DOJ's Second Amendment section has used against state and local gun laws
The county had already trimmed the bill before the lawsuit. The revision removed several additional sensitive places. The Supreme Court of Maryland had ordered those changes in a separate case. That court found that restrictions on carrying at hospitals, community health centers, long-term care facilities, childcare facilities, and public protests likely went beyond what a history-informed Second Amendment allows. DOJ argued the bill was "presumptively unconstitutional" and that any county enforcement would constitute a "pattern or practice" of rights violations. Judge Chuang found DOJ never identified a single act of enforcement. He called the complaint essentially a facial challenge to restrictions on private citizens. He wrote that the bill cannot itself show a pattern of police misconduct. He also noted that "there is no precedent" for the government's use of the statute.
Background
The pattern-or-practice statute gives the Attorney General authority to sue government entities whose officers engage in patterns of conduct that violate constitutional rights. Federal prosecutors have historically used it against police departments accused of systemic abuse. Over the past few years, DOJ's Second Amendment section has pointed the same statute at state and local firearms laws. Montgomery County is one of the first places where a federal judge has ruled on that approach in a sensitive places case. The result is a clear rejection. A statute built to police officer misconduct does not transform a carry restriction into a civil rights violation by police. The Montgomery County dispute also ties into the Maryland high court ruling that forced the county to strip out its hospital and protest restrictions. Maryland courts have now shown they will scrutinize carry bans using the Bruen framework, but the county still defended the core 100-yard buffer.
Why It Matters for Gun Owners
If you carry in Montgomery County, the buffer still applies. Parks, libraries, schools, places of worship, and courthouses remain off-limits under Chapter 57. Dismissing DOJ's suit does not repeal the ordinance. It only removes federal pressure from the case. Private challenges can still move forward, and the county's remaining restrictions will face scrutiny from gun rights groups. Residents who carry near a fairground, conference center, or polling place should read the exact definitions in the code. The definition reaches privately owned venues too, which catches many people off guard. Watch for private plaintiffs filing their own suits and for any appeal from DOJ. Gun owners across Maryland and in other jurisdictions with similar sensitive places rules should expect this template to spread. Carry with a map of every covered location before you leave the house.
DownRange Analysis
The DOJ theory was weak from the start. Bruen requires the government to justify firearm regulations with historical analogues. DOJ skipped that work entirely and tried to win on a procedural shortcut. Judge Chuang saw through it. The more important question is whether the 100-yard buffer survives a Bruen challenge on its merits. A buffer covering parks, schools, and places of worship has some historical support in the analogues courts have accepted, but the breadth of the definition and the inclusion of privately owned venues will invite hard questions. Gun owners should not treat this dismissal as a win on the merits. It is a procedural victory for the county. Carriers should document their routes, keep their carry permits current, and support local litigation that tests the definition. Pushing back at the county council level still matters.




