Supreme Court Denies Challenge to Maryland's 'Gun-Free Zones'
HOME›NEWS›LAW
LAW

SCOTUS Passes on Maryland Gun-Free Zone Fight, Leaving Carry Bans Intact

The Supreme Court denied review of Novotny v. Moore on Monday, leaving the Fourth Circuit's ruling that upheld most of Maryland's sensitive-place carry bans. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that he doubts many of these laws are constitutional, but he still voted to deny.

Bearing Arms|November 16, 2026|2d ago|4 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

SCOTUS Passes on Novotny, Leaving Maryland's Carry Bans Intact

The Supreme Court declined on Monday to hear Novotny v. Moore, a challenge to Maryland's expanded list of “sensitive places” where licensed carriers cannot bring firearms. The justices left in place a Fourth Circuit decision that upheld most of those restrictions. Justice Clarence Thomas filed a written statement. He said he doubts many of these laws match the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation, yet he still agreed with the denial. Maryland carriers keep living under the current rules, and the Court signals it will wait for a cleaner vehicle.

Key Details

  • Case: Novotny v. Moore, challenging Maryland's post-Bruen sensitive-place provisions. Cert denied Monday, November 16, 2026.
  • Lower court: The Fourth Circuit upheld most of the challenged Maryland restrictions. That ruling stands.
  • Thomas's position: He is skeptical that each Maryland statute fits the historical tradition test. He wrote that the breadth of the challenge would complicate review, because each law rests on a distinct historical tradition.
  • Thomas's proposed path: A narrower case would let the Court examine how far states may go in banning carry in sensitive places.
  • Thomas on scope creep: He wrote that states have used the “sensitive places” label to bar carry in locations that look nothing like legislatures, polling places, or courthouses.
  • New Jersey: Bars firearms in at least 25 locations, including zoos, public libraries, casinos, and state-owned beaches.
  • New York: Designates 20 locations as sensitive, ranging from places of worship to certain licensed residential facilities.
  • California: Lists 29 gun-free categories, including athletic facilities, financial institutions, and government-permitted public gatherings.
  • Christian v. James: Challenges New York's ban on carry in public parks. New York's response brief is due December 3.
  • Schoenthal v. Raoul: Challenges the ban on carry in public transportation. The Court declined that case last term.
  • Colie v. Commonwealth of Virginia: Cert denied the same day. A concealed carrier was acquitted on most charges after shooting a YouTube prankster who confronted him. He was convicted only of unlawful discharge in an occupied building.

Background

In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022), the Court struck down New York's proper-cause requirement for carry permits. It also set a test: states must show a restriction fits within the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. States responded by expanding their lists of sensitive places. Maryland, New York, New Jersey, and California all enacted broad lists after the ruling. In United States v. Rahimi (2024), the Court clarified that courts do not need a historical twin for every modern law. Lower courts, particularly in the Second and Fourth Circuits, have upheld large portions of these lists. The Court has now struck down Hawaii's default ban on carry in private property open to the public. That decision shows the justices still police carry restrictions. Yet they have left the sensitive-places question alone for now, despite repeated petitions.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

If you carry in Maryland, New Jersey, New York, or California, this order changes nothing about your legal exposure. A sensitive-place list that a court has upheld is enforceable against you. Maryland permit holders should map every location on the state's list before entering a building, park, or venue. New Jersey and New York carriers face the widest gaps, since parks, libraries, and public spaces appear on those lists. Carriers who travel face a patchwork. A permit valid in one state gives no protection in a neighboring one that bans carry in parks or transit. Pay attention to posted signage, but do not assume a missing sign means the location is open. Watch the December 3 deadline in Christian v. James. A New York park ban is a cleaner test case than Maryland's sprawling statute. Any Supreme Court action on that petition will matter more to New York carriers than anything in Novotny.

DownRange Analysis

Thomas's statement reads like a roadmap. He doubts these laws survive Bruen, yet he declined to say so in a ruling. That leaves four votes for a future grant as the real question. A denial is not a merits decision, and it sets no precedent for or against Maryland's law. Still, the Court's pattern is clear. It takes narrow cases and avoids sprawling challenges. Each narrow case costs years and money, and that is the trap. A state can keep a ban alive while plaintiffs fund one lawsuit at a time. What should you do right now? Know the sensitive-place list for every state you carry in. Support the litigation groups that file these cases. If your state has a restriction that blocks everyday life, such as a park or public library ban, document the restriction and talk to a lawyer about a challenge. Do not carry where the law forbids it while waiting for the Court to act.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
sensitive-placesmarylandnovotny-v-mooresupreme-courtbruencarry-restrictionssecond-amendmentchristian-v-james
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK