Taking Savannah Mayor to Task Over Open-Carry Comments
HOME›NEWS›OPINION
OPINION

Savannah Mayor Admits AR-15 Open Carry Walk Is Legal

Savannah Mayor Van Johnson called a man's open-carry walks with an AR-15-style rifle a stunt, while conceding the conduct is legal. Bearing Arms columnist responded that the mayor's line tying the Second Amendment to second graders makes no sense when no one was hurt.

Bearing Arms|November 16, 2026|2d ago|4 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

Savannah Mayor Calls AR-15 Open-Carry Walk a 'Stunt'

Savannah Mayor Van Johnson publicly dismissed a man's open-carry walks through downtown as a stunt, even though he admits the conduct is not illegal. The man, identified as Tlacuatl, carried an AR-15-style rifle through busy areas of Savannah, Georgia. Johnson said his main concern was how residents and visitors would react. He also questioned Tlacuatl's motives, pointing to videos of the walks posted on social media. His most quoted line tied gun rights to child safety: "We believe that we can protect the Second Amendment and protect second graders." Bearing Arms published a commentary on the exchange on November 16, 2026, and the writer rejected the mayor's framing.

Key Details

The facts in the exchange are straightforward. Johnson's objections rest on public reaction and motive, not on any violation of law.

  • Location: Downtown Savannah, Georgia.
  • Who: Tlacuatl, who carried an AR-15-style rifle during several walks.
  • Legal status: Johnson acknowledged that Tlacuatl's actions are not illegal under the circumstances described.
  • Tlacuatl's position: He said most people he encountered were positive, and that openly exercising rights keeps them from eroding over time.
  • Johnson's position: He called the walks a stunt, said people seek attention this way, and argued that protecting rights should include considering the safety of others.
  • Columnist's counterclaim: The writer says the Savannah City Council violated Georgia's preemption law by passing a measure that penalized victims of vehicle-based gun thefts. The column makes this claim without further detail in the piece.
  • Publication date: November 16, 2026.

Background

Georgia is a permitless carry state. The state's 2022 law let adults carry handguns without a license, and it has long allowed open carry for those who are legally eligible. Local governments in Georgia cannot pass their own firearms rules under the state's preemption statute, codified at O.C.G.A. § 16-11-173. That statute is the reason the columnist frames the city council's vehicle-theft ordinance as a state law violation.

The Supreme Court's 2008 decision in District of Columbia v. Heller recognized an individual right to keep and bear arms. The 2010 decision in McDonald v. Chicago applied that right to the states. In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022), the Court struck down New York's may-issue carry permit scheme and set a test: regulations must fit within the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. Public officials who criticize lawful carry often do so without addressing that test. Johnson's remarks reflect a policy preference, not a legal finding that the walks broke any rule.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

This dispute affects anyone who carries in Georgia, especially in cities with active local governments. Preemption protects residents from a patchwork of local gun laws. Savannah's council can debate and criticize, but it cannot add a new carry prohibition that the state does not authorize. Gun owners in Atlanta, Savannah, Augusta, and other Georgia cities should know which local rules apply to them and which ones are void under state law.

The practical risk is not the walk itself. The risk is the response. Officials, police, and bystanders may react to a rifle in public even when the carrier is lawful. Anyone who carries a long gun openly should know the state's rules, keep the firearm in a lawful manner, and assume that a phone is recording. Video helps the carrier if a situation escalates, and it also spreads the encounter online. Watch for city council agendas that touch firearms, and watch for ordinances that the state may later challenge.

DownRange Analysis

Johnson's statement fails the Bruen test in one important way. He did not identify a victim, a threat, or a crime. He cited public discomfort and the perceived motive of the carrier. Public discomfort is not a historical justification for a carry ban. Under Bruen, the government must show a historical analogue for a restriction, and a mayor's objection to a visible rifle does not meet that burden.

The column's logic is also sound on a basic point. Exercising rights keeps them in use, and rights rarely erode in the courts alone. For the market, a single walk changes nothing. AR-15 demand follows federal policy, state law, and price, not one mayor's comments. What gun owners should do now is simple. Learn the preemption statute, know which local rules are void, document any encounter with officials or police, and contact council members when local proposals cross the line. Carry lawfully, and make your case with facts rather than theatrics.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
open-carrysavannahgeorgiasecond-amendmentar-15gun-politicspreemption
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK