Detroit Carjack Victim Fired Back. St. Louis Driver Faces No Charges.
A Detroit carjacking target pulled his own gun and shot both would-be robbers, killing one of them at the scene. In St. Louis, prosecutors declined to charge a driver who fatally shot Vance Townes, 59, during a road-rage confrontation in a parking lot on September 22. The Detroit attack happened last Friday night. The St. Louis shooting is older, and prosecutors only recently announced their decision. Both cases land on the same question gun owners face every day: when an armed person approaches your vehicle, what are you legally allowed to do? The answers in these two cases differ, and the details explain why.
Key Details
The Detroit incident started when two suspects in their 20s approached a Hyundai Elantra and announced a robbery. Two people were inside the car. The suspects forced both occupants out and onto their knees. According to the victim, one suspect then told the other to shoot them. One occupant drew a gun and fired, hitting both suspects. Police pronounced one suspect dead at the scene. The other was taken to the hospital.
- Detroit location: Hyundai Elantra, attempted carjacking, reported last Friday night
- Detroit suspects: two men in their 20s; one dead, one hospitalized
- St. Louis victim: Vance Townes, 59, shot and killed around 11 PM on September 22
- St. Louis shooter: a driver in a Honda who fired five shots from inside his car
- Trigger: Townes passed the Honda, honked and yelled, and both drivers pulled into a parking lot
- Weapons: police say both men drew guns, but only the Honda driver fired
- Passengers: a woman and two children were in the Honda
- Criminal history: police say the Honda driver has no criminal record
- Prosecution decision: no charges, with prosecutors calling the legal elements of self-defense "insurmountable"
Surveillance video obtained by FOX 2 shows the Honda driver waiting at a green light before turning the wrong way into the lot where Townes had stopped at an ATM. Townes walked toward the parked Honda holding a handgun at his side. The driver, still seated, opened fire. Trial attorney Jay Kanzler told reporters that a driver seated inside a vehicle who faces an armed approach has a clear legal right to shoot under state law.
Background
Self-defense law in both states rests on the same core rule: you may use deadly force when you reasonably believe you face imminent death or serious bodily harm. The details vary. In 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court decided New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen and struck down New York's "proper cause" licensing requirement. The Court also set a test that asks whether modern regulation fits the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. That ruling did not directly address self-defense standards, but it reinforced that the Second Amendment protects armed self-defense outside the home.
Missouri's constitution guarantees the right to keep and bear arms, and the state removed the duty to retreat in public places through a 2017 law. Michigan's self-defense statute, revised in 2006, allows a person to use force when facing an unlawful threat, and it removes the duty to retreat where a person has a legal right to be. Carjackings in Detroit have long been a serious concern. The state treats armed robbery and carjacking as violent felonies, which means police and prosecutors see armed attackers as a clear threat rather than a gray-area dispute.
Why It Matters for Gun Owners
The Detroit case shows what a defensive shooting looks like when the facts are clean. The attackers announced their intent, ordered victims to their knees, and reportedly told a third party to shoot. That is a textbook imminent threat. Gun owners in Michigan should understand that the legal question is not whether the attacker has a gun in hand at that moment. It is whether the threat is immediate and the response is proportionate.
The St. Louis case shows the opposite risk. The shooter may have made a poor choice by following Townes into the lot after a verbal confrontation. Townes also made choices that escalated things. Still, prosecutors focused on the moment Townes walked toward the driver's car with a handgun. Missouri owners who carry need to know that a road-rage argument can end with a shooting, and that every decision before the trigger pull will get examined later. Keep your car as a place to disengage, not a place to fight. Pull away from aggressive drivers and call 911 when someone escalates.
DownRange Analysis
The Detroit shooting passes a Bruen-style test with ease. Armed suspects gave a clear command to kill, and the victim responded with a single defensive act. Nobody needs a historical analogue to justify that response. The St. Louis case is harder. The Honda driver had two children in the car and a legitimate reason to fear an armed man approaching. Still, the decision to drive into that lot was a choice, and courts will weigh that choice. Prosecutors reached a defensible conclusion, but the shooter's judgment is what a good instructor would tear apart in a class.
For the market, expect more demand for training on vehicle-based defense and de-escalation. Carry owners should practice drawing from a seated position, and they should rehearse leaving a bad situation before they rehearse shooting. Know your state's vehicle and self-defense statutes before you need them. Your best defense is never being the person who turned a traffic dispute into a gunfight. Stay out of the parking lot.




