Twenty days. That's how long until the justices hear oral argument in Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins on Dec. 2. Cook County is trying to make sure one of those two arguments never happens.
What Cook County Is Asking For
The Second Amendment Foundation filed a reply at the U.S. Supreme Court this week. It urges the justices to keep Viramontes alive after the county argued the case should be dismissed as moot. You can read our full coverage of the SAF filing here.
Plain English: "moot" means there's nothing left for the court to decide. If the Court agrees with the county, the case goes away, and so does the chance to rule on it. A county that has spent years defending its ban could end up never having to defend it before the highest court in the country.
I won't speculate on the county's reasoning beyond what's in the briefing. The result is what matters. If you're a gun owner in a jurisdiction with an assault weapons ban, a dismissal would be a loss with nothing on the record to show for it.
Why a Mootness Dodge Should Bother You
I have no patience for procedural escape hatches in civil rights cases. Nobody gets to dodge a First Amendment challenge by tweaking the policy the week before argument. Gun owners shouldn't have to put up with it either.
The Court set these cases for argument. That tells you the justices see something worth deciding. Now the county wants to pull one of them off the calendar. SAF is right to fight it, and the Court should deny the motion and take up the merits.
If Viramontes survives, Dec. 2 is a real day. If it doesn't, we're left with one argument instead of two, and everyone who was counting on a clean look at these bans has to start over.
Illinois and Connecticut: What to Watch
If you live in Illinois, the stakes are obvious. Viramontes is a Cook County case, and the outcome will shape how bans like it are treated well beyond one county. Check where your own rights stand on our Illinois law page.
Connecticut owners should be watching just as closely. Grant v. Higgins shares the Dec. 2 argument date, and Connecticut has its own assault weapons restrictions. Whatever the Court says or doesn't say about the Cook County case will be read in Hartford. Our Connecticut law page has the current rules.
Don't expect a decision on Dec. 2. Oral argument is the start, not the finish. Plan on waiting for a ruling after that, and don't let anyone tell you they can predict it from the questions at argument. I've watched enough of these to know that's tea-leaf reading.
Ohio, New York, and Texas: Other Fronts This Week
The same week brought news in three more states.
- Ohio: The House Public Safety Committee advanced Senate Bill 214 with Gun Owners of America amendments that de-regulate short-barreled firearms. Good. But it still needs a House floor vote, Senate concurrence, and the governor's signature. A committee vote isn't a law. Our Ohio law page has the current status.
- New York: A jury convicted Demetrio Daga of 15 weapons counts in September. State police started the case by tracking his eBay purchases of legal gun parts. Sentencing is set for Nov. 30 in Albany County. Read that again: legal parts bought online put a man on a state police radar. See our New York law page.
- Texas: Texas Gun Rights is warning that Rep. Senfronia Thompson's bid for House Speaker could move gun-control measures forward. The group cites her 2019 caucus letter calling for red-flag confiscation and her votes against Constitutional Carry and church carry. That's the group's case, and the votes and the letter are the record it points to. Our Texas law page shows what's at stake.
Different states, same pattern. The fights that decide your rights happen in committee rooms, speaker races, and state police investigations, not only in the Supreme Court.
What You Should Do Now
Here's my list, in order of how much it matters.
- Mark Dec. 2. Follow Viramontes and Grant v. Higgins. Pay attention to whether Viramontes stays on the calendar.
- Back the groups doing the filing. SAF is carrying the Cook County fight at the Supreme Court. Briefs cost money, and membership is how it gets paid for.
- Ohio: Call your House member and tell them to bring SB 214 to the floor. Committee wins die quietly all the time.
- Texas: Find out where your state representative stands on the Speaker race before it's decided. After the vote is too late.
- New York: Watch Daga's sentencing on Nov. 30. If you buy gun parts online, keep your receipts and know your state's rules cold. If you're unsure whether a build is legal, ask a New York firearms attorney before you buy, not after the knock on the door.
None of this takes long. A phone call to a legislator takes five minutes. A donation takes two.
DownRange Bottom Line: Cook County is trying to win by making the case disappear, and SAF is making the Supreme Court say no on the record. Dec. 2 will tell us whether Viramontes gets its day. Meanwhile, Ohio's SB 214 still has three steps left, Texas gun owners need to watch the Speaker race, and New York is showing what happens when legal parts purchases draw the wrong attention. Don't wait for a ruling to act. Join the fight, call your legislators, and know your state's law before somebody else tests it for you.

