First Circuit Reopens Gun Case Over Two Old Massachusetts DUIs
The First Circuit Court of Appeals partly revived Thomas Marshall's challenge to the federal gun ban on November 13 in Marshall v. Blanche. Marshall's prohibition traces to two Massachusetts DUIs, dated 1997 and 2005. He moved to New Hampshire in 2023, tried to buy a handgun, and a background check stopped the sale. The panel sent parts of his case back to a federal trial court. Marshall remains prohibited from possessing firearms. The ruling does not declare the ban unconstitutional as applied to him, and the court did not rule on the merits of his claim. The opinion still changes how federal judges in New England must handle these cases.
Key Details
The facts that drive this ruling are concrete and few:
- Thomas Marshall was convicted of DUI in 1997 and again in 2005, both in Massachusetts.
- Federal law under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) bars anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year in prison. State misdemeanors punishable by two years or less fall outside that rule.
- Massachusetts classifies a first or second DUI as a misdemeanor, but the maximum sentence is two and a half years. That six-month gap places the offense inside the federal ban.
- Marshall filed suit in June 2024 in New Hampshire federal court. He seeks a handgun and a long gun for home defense.
- U.S. District Judge Paul Barbadoro dismissed the case in June 2025, relying on United States v. Torres-Rosario, a 2011 First Circuit decision.
- On November 13, the First Circuit vacated part of that dismissal. The panel found Marshall lacks standing to challenge the possession ban as written, but his challenge to the background check denial returns to the trial court.
- The panel noted that New Hampshire had at least 30 licensed gun manufacturing facilities in 2023. A firearm made in-state might never cross a state line, which matters because the ban reaches only guns that moved in interstate or foreign commerce.
- The Justice Department's rights restoration rule allows prohibited persons to apply for relief. The court called a remand "particularly appropriate" given that process.
Background
The Second Amendment argument against 922(g)(1) has grown over the past decade, and the Supreme Court's 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen changed the analysis. Bruen requires the government to show that a firearm regulation fits within the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. Before Bruen, the First Circuit's approach in Torres-Rosario made as-applied challenges to the felon ban nearly impossible to win. Marshall's trial court relied on that older precedent.
The shift came in September, when the First Circuit applied the Bruen framework in United States v. Levasseur. Levasseur, a Maine man, challenged his own 922(g)(1) conviction on as-applied grounds and lost. The Marshall panel nonetheless concluded that Levasseur displaced Torres-Rosario as controlling authority. Lower courts in Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Puerto Rico now must perform the historical analysis rather than dismiss these claims on the old precedent alone.
Why It Matters for Gun Owners
This ruling reaches anyone with an old misdemeanor DUI, assault, or similar charge in the First Circuit states. Massachusetts and Rhode Island residents with decades-old state convictions carry the same federal exposure Marshall does. The problem gets worse for people who moved across state lines. A background check run in New Hampshire, Maine, or another state will pull the same record that Massachusetts court files contain. If your record includes a state misdemeanor with a maximum above one year, you are prohibited regardless of how long ago it happened. Check the actual statutory maximum, not the label the state uses. Pull your certified court disposition before you assume a purchase will clear. If you already got denied, you have a path. The DOJ restoration process exists, and it is worth filing if your offense falls outside the rule's presumptive denial categories. Watch the trial court in New Hampshire for the Bruen history analysis, because its outcome will shape which offenses courts treat as dangerous enough to permanently disarm.
DownRange Analysis
The standing holding is the weak point. The panel told Marshall he cannot challenge a ban on guns he has not shown he will own, and that gun may never have crossed state lines. That reasoning is narrow, but it hands the government an easy exit in future cases. Marshall's background check claim carries more weight, because a denied purchase is a concrete injury. The trial judge will need to apply Bruen's history test to a misdemeanor DUI, and that test is harder for the government than the old Torres-Rosario framework. Expect the DOJ to argue that drunk driving convictions track the historical disarmament of dangerous people. Gun owners should watch whether the court accepts that framing. My read: the restoration rule may get Marshall his gun before any court rules on the merits. Anyone in his position should apply through DOJ now and preserve the litigation in parallel.




