These 9 Gun Writers Pick Their Single Favorite Shotgun of All Time
HOME›NEWS›NEWS
NEWS

Gun Writers' Top Shotguns Are Mostly Discontinued or Used Now

Outdoor Life Guns asked nine shotgun writers to name one favorite smoothbore. The picks included a Sig-branded Rizzini double, a Beretta ASEL, a Remington 3200, and a Ruger Red Label. Several of these guns now sell used for far less than new-gun prices.

Outdoor Life Guns|November 13, 2026|5d ago|4 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

Beretta's Custom ASEL Sells Used for $3,000–$5,000, Writers Say

A hand-built Beretta ASEL over/under now trades for $3,000 to $5,000 on the used market, and one shotgun writer calls it a steal. Outdoor Life Guns asked nine working shotgun writers to name one favorite smoothbore each. The answers ran from a Sig-branded Rizzini over/under to a Remington 3200 to a Ruger Red Label. Several writers chose a sturdy break-action or pump, and they cited reliability as the reason. A break-action has no shells to cycle, so it has fewer ways to quit. The list also included affordable guns, which tells you these writers know value when they see it.

Key Details

The writers answered with guns they have shot, hunted with, and trusted over years of testing. Here is what each pick brings to the table:

  • Snow's pick: The Sig TR 20 U Aurora, built by Rizzini. It has a color-case-hardened receiver with modest scroll engraving and a finished walnut stock. The stock is straight, which is unusual on an over/under.
  • Bourjaily's pick: A custom Beretta ASEL 12-gauge. His mother bought the gun in the 1960s with a small inheritance. Orvis gunsmiths restored the steel after his father gave it to him in rough shape.
  • New ASEL pricing: A new 12-gauge runs about $12,000. The 20-gauge version costs nearly double that.
  • Roster's pick: The Remington 3200, the second iteration of the 32. He owns two of them and had custom 28-, 20-, 12-gauge (3½-inch chamber), and 10-gauge (3½-inch chamber) barrels built to fit the actions.
  • Roster's round count: He estimates hundreds of thousands of rounds through each 3200 with almost no mechanical issues. He also shoots two Beretta 686s in 20 and 28 gauge, plus a 3-inch .410 Browning Feather XS. He reports tens of thousands of rounds through those three guns with zero malfunctions.
  • Spomer's pick: A 28-gauge Ruger Red Label. Used examples sell for about $1,000.

Background

Battista Rizzini has built shotguns since 1966, producing both high-end and more affordable doubles. Rizzini later made a run of guns for Sig Sauer, including the TR 20 U Aurora that Snow picked. That business relationship went sideways, and those guns now surface only on the used market. The Beretta ASEL is an Italian-made custom over/under that earned its reputation as a hand-built, high-grade gun. Remington's 32 came first, and the 3200 followed as its second iteration. The original 32 was discontinued during World War II. Ruger started the Red Label in the late 1970s to compete with Browning's Superposed. The line ran for about four decades. The over/under market then filled with inexpensive break-actions, which made it hard for Ruger to compete. Ruger discontinued the Red Label in 2011, tried to revive it in 2013, and could not sell enough guns to keep it in production. Roster's career also reaches back to the lead era. He helped develop early steel waterfowl loads before the lead ban took effect in the early 1990s.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

If you shop for a break-action, the used market is where the value sits. A new ASEL costs roughly $12,000, while a used one can cost a third of that. Ruger's Red Label gives you a trim, light American over/under for around $1,000 used. Buyers should treat any used break-action as a project until a gunsmith confirms it. Check the barrels, the locking lugs, the action, and the forend for wear. Look for cracks, loose ribs, and replaced parts. If you plan to buy a Remington 3200, look for the lack of side ribs along the double barrels, which identifies the model. Confirm that any barrel set fits the receiver and carries the correct gauge and chamber markings. Mismatched barrels cause problems, and a fit check costs far less than a bad purchase. Finally, decide how you will use the gun. Hunting shotguns, clay guns, and testing guns all get used differently, and the writers' picks show that the right gun depends on the job.

DownRange Analysis

Nothing here involves a court ruling, so Bruen does not apply to this piece. Bruen matters when a state tries to restrict which firearms you can own, and these writers simply named favorites. The market lesson still matters. Hand-built Italian over/unders have lost value on the used market while new prices climbed, and that gap works in your favor if you buy carefully. Ruger's discontinued Red Label shows the opposite lesson. A good gun can sell cheap when the market floods with inexpensive competitors. Our advice is simple. Buy used, pay for a gunsmith inspection, and avoid paying new-gun money for a shotgun that already proved itself in the field. If you want a gun that goes bang every time, the writers already pointed you to the right platform: a break-action or pump with no cycling to fail.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
shotgunsover-underused-gunsberetta-aselremington-3200ruger-red-labelgun-writers
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK