Laramie Gun Owner Pleads to Reckless Endangering After Drawing on Three Men
Rihanna Kelver, 28, entered a no-contest plea to reckless endangering in a Laramie, Wyoming case that began when she drew a pistol on three men outside a downtown bar. Sentencing is set for early December. Kelver announced the deal on Facebook, while insisting she broke no Wyoming law. The plea removes the possibility of a 15-year prison term, and probation is the expected sentence. The case drew national attention after The New York Times framed it as a test of Wyoming's stand-your-ground statute. This is not a self-defense win. It is a negotiated outcome, and it should be read that way.
Key Details
The facts that matter come from court records, police reports, and surveillance footage cited in coverage of the case:
- Date and place: September 13, outside the Crowbar and Grill in downtown Laramie.
- The trigger: A man in a group of three shouted a profanity at the bar. Kelver says another man, Scott Durham, also yelled an anti-gay slur. Durham denied the slur to police.
- The approach: Kelver walked into the street toward the men, one hand on her hip near the pack holding her gun, and asked what they had said.
- The shove: Durham pushed her away. Kelver stumbled and landed on her back.
- The draw: As she hit the pavement, Kelver drew and racked the pistol and pointed it at the group. She did not fire.
- Duration: The encounter lasted about 10 seconds. The three men walked away.
- Plea: Kelver pleaded no contest to reckless endangering. The original exposure included up to 15 years in prison.
- Sentencing: Early December. Probation is the likely result.
- Expungement: Cowboy State Daily reported that the charge could be fully expunged if Kelver completes probation.
Background
The New York Times published a sympathetic profile of Kelver in August under the headline "A Trans Woman Pulled a Gun and Started a 'Stand Your Ground' Debate." The piece leaned on Wyoming's stand-your-ground law to ask why a person who had been shoved was being prosecuted. Bearing Arms contributor Tom Knighton answered that question soon after. Prosecutors and the judge overseeing the case did not accept that Kelver faced a threat of death or serious injury when she drew. Stand-your-ground protection depends on a reasonable belief of imminent danger. A shove, an insult, or an argument does not meet that bar on its own. Wyoming is also a permitless carry state, so Kelver could legally carry without a state permit. Permitless carry does not change the rules on when a gun may be pointed at another person. Federal law bars anyone convicted of a felony from possessing firearms under 18 U.S.C. 922(g)(1). That is why plea structure matters so much to a carrier facing a charge.
Why It Matters for Gun Owners
This case shows how a self-defense claim gets decided in practice. Most criminal cases end in plea agreements, not jury verdicts. A carrier who draws a gun and then argues justification at trial takes a gamble that few can afford. Any gun owner who carries in a stand-your-ground state should understand three things. First, the draw itself is the use of force that gets scrutinized, not just the shot. Second, a gun in your hand can convert a verbal fight into a felony-level case in a matter of seconds. Third, prosecutors look at video. Surveillance footage from a downtown camera captured the sequence in this case, and it likely shaped the charge. If you carry in public, assume every draw will be recorded. Review your state's use-of-force statute now, not after an incident. Know the difference between a threat that justifies deadly force and an insult that does not.
DownRange Analysis
Bruen governs who may carry, not when a gun may be pointed at someone. New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen struck down New York's discretionary carry permit regime and set a text-and-history test for regulating arms. It did not create a right to draw on people who shove you. Justification for force sits in state law, and courts will apply it case by case. Kelver's outcome is a reasonable one for her, but the lesson is narrow. Her Second Amendment rights survived because the plea avoided a felony, not because the draw was defensible. Gun owners should treat that distinction as the real takeaway. Practice verbal de-escalation, retreat when you can, and reserve a drawn pistol for an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm. The best defensive outcome is still walking away.




