.45 Colt vs .45 Long Colt: Same Cartridge? (2026)
HOME›NEWS›TRAINING
TRAINING

Same Round, Two Names: .45 Colt Is .45 Long Colt, Period

GunsAmerica Digest confirms .45 Colt and .45 Long Colt are one rimmed cartridge from the 1873 Colt Single Action Army. The real danger is confusing it with .45 ACP, .454 Casull, or the .410 shotshell.

GunsAmerica Digest|November 17, 2026|1d ago|4 min read|ORIGINAL SOURCE ↗

.45 Colt and .45 Long Colt Are the Same Round, Period

A box marked .45 Colt and a barrel stamped .45 Long Colt or .45 LC describe the same cartridge. GunsAmerica Digest made that point in a November 2026 guide, and the logic holds. The rimmed, straight-walled round dates to the Colt Single Action Army of 1873. Its two names come from history, not from different case dimensions or pressure standards. No factory hides a second product behind either label. The real risk lies in rounds that look similar on a shelf: .45 ACP, .454 Casull, .460 S&W, and the .410 shotshell. Those are different cartridges, and mixing them up can wreck a gun or hurt the shooter.

Key Details

The guide lists .45 Colt, .45 Long Colt, .45 LC, and 45 Colt as interchangeable names. Ammunition labeled with any of them fits a gun labeled with any of them, provided the gun is in sound condition and the load suits it. Key figures from the piece and its linked reviews:

  • The original black powder load pushed a 255 grain bullet at about 850 fps, roughly 409 ft-lb, according to Robert Sadowski.
  • Trapr Swonson says modern factory .45 Colt loads run from mild 800 fps offerings to about 1,500 fps.
  • Sadowski's Cimarron U.S.V. Artillery, a 5.5 inch replica of the Colt Artillery Model, was regulated at 15 yards out of the box.
  • From a rest, Winchester Defender 225 grain bonded hollow points averaged just over 2.25 inches for six shots. Hornady Cowboy 255 grain loads averaged 2 inches.
  • Rob Garrett's Lipsey's Ruger Blackhawk Flattop Bisley Taffin tribute ran a Lost River 270 grain Keith semi-wadcutter at 936 fps with a 4.5 inch group. A High Desert 250 grain load ran 746 fps with a 4 inch group.
  • Henry offers its Big Boy Carbine in .45 Colt. Sam Trisler's .44 Magnum test gun had a 16.5 inch octagon barrel, held seven rounds, and grouped just under 2 inches at 100 yards with irons.
  • Paul Helinski ran Hornady 225 grain FTX from a 2 inch Taurus Judge Public Defender Poly at 735 fps, about 200 fps slower than the same load from a rifle.
  • Garrett's Ruger came with a separate .45 ACP cylinder. The S&W Governor uses moon clips to fire both calibers.

Background

The Colt round earned its "Long" tag because the Army once had two .45 revolver cartridges in service. Smith & Wesson's Model 3, built from 1868 to 1898, saw small-scale purchases by the U.S. Army. After design changes by Major George W. Schofield, that Army version became known as the Schofield. Original S&W Americans were chambered for the shorter .45 Schofield. With two .45s in the supply chain, soldiers and armorers needed a way to separate them. The longer Colt cartridge became the "Long." The nickname outlasted the Schofield's Army service and stuck to the Colt round for good.

Later .45 designs took separate paths. .45 ACP arrived as a rimless pistol cartridge built around Colt's autoloading pistol, a shorter round that never shared the Colt's case length. The .454 Casull and .460 S&W came decades later as high-pressure magnum rounds. The .410 shotshell matches the .45 Colt's rim and body dimensions, which is why the Taurus Judge exists. Shooters keep confusing these because of rim and body overlap, not because the names overlap.

Why It Matters for Gun Owners

Anyone who owns a single action, a replica, or a .410/.45 Colt revolver needs to read the chamber markings and the ammo box together. The rule runs one way. .45 Colt fires in a .454 Casull chamber and in a .460 S&W chamber, but .454 and .460 rounds never belong in a .45 Colt gun. Buyers of older Colt SAA originals and cowboy replicas should stay with low-pressure cowboy loads. Lever guns and modern Rugers built for stronger loads can handle the hotter factory ammo, but only when the maker's specs say so. Keep .45 ACP out of .45 Colt chambers, and never load .410 shotshells into a .45 Colt chamber. Those mistakes cause injuries, and warranty claims won't help after the fact.

DownRange Analysis

This is a nomenclature question, not a Second Amendment fight, so Bruen does not factor in. The market does care, though. Retailers sell the same round under two names, and some shooters pay a premium for a "Long Colt" label that means nothing new. Compare price per round and check the grain weight and stated velocity. A 255 grain Cowboy load and a 270 grain hot load are not the same purchase. Before you buy a load for a new gun, confirm the manufacturer's pressure rating in writing. Run your own chronograph session if you can. Use mild loads in replicas and original SAAs, save the hotter stuff for guns built to take it, and keep the .45 ACP and .410 ammo bins separate. The label on the box matters less than the gun it goes into.

ORIGINAL SOURCE
This editorial was written by DownRange based on the original article. Read the primary source for additional detail.
READ ORIGINAL ↗
TAGS
45-colt45-long-coltrevolver-ammunitionsingle-action-revolverstaurus-judgehenry-big-boycartridge-identificationreloading-safety
SHARE:X / TWITTERFACEBOOK